Chapter 20: Entropy and the Second Law of Thermodynamics
Beta Version: Some equations may not render correctly (try Chrome/Firefox, clear cache, or refresh). Solutions, videos, and animations coming soon!
The second law of thermodynamics and the concept of entropy govern the direction of natural processes, from the efficiency of rocket engines to the inevitable increase of disorder in the universe. Building on the thermodynamic principles from Chapters 18 and 19, this chapter explores the fundamental laws that dictate energy transformations and irreversibility. For JEE Main, JEE Advanced, and NEET students, mastering these concepts is essential, as they appear in problems involving heat engines, refrigerators, and entropy changes. This chapter, Entropy and the Second Law of Thermodynamics, covers the second law and irreversibility, entropy and its calculation, heat engines and refrigerators, and the Carnot cycle and efficiency, providing detailed explanations, derivations, solved examples, and practical applications to ensure conceptual clarity and problem-solving proficiency.
20.1 The Second Law of Thermodynamics and Irreversibility
The second law of thermodynamics establishes the direction of natural processes, introducing the concept of irreversibility, a fundamental principle for JEE/NEET thermodynamics problems.
Statements of the Second Law
- Kelvin-Planck Statement: It is impossible to construct a device that operates in a cycle and converts all the heat absorbed from a single reservoir into work (no 100% efficient heat engine).
- Clausius Statement: It is impossible to construct a device that operates in a cycle and transfers heat from a colder body to a hotter body without external work (heat cannot flow from cold to hot spontaneously). These statements are equivalent and imply a direction for thermodynamic processes.
Irreversibility
- Reversible Process: A process that can be reversed without changing the system or surroundings (e.g., ideal isothermal expansion). Requires quasi-static conditions (infinitesimal steps).
- Irreversible Process: A process that cannot be reversed without external intervention (e.g., heat flow from hot to cold, gas free expansion). Most real processes are irreversible due to friction, mixing, or heat loss.
Direction of Processes
The second law dictates that natural processes proceed in a direction that increases the total entropy of the system and surroundings, leading to irreversibility in real systems.
Derivation: Equivalence of Kelvin-Planck and Clausius Statements
Assume a device violates the Clausius statement: it transfers heat
Derivation: Irreversibility of Heat Flow
Consider two reservoirs: hot at
Derivation: Irreversible Free Expansion
A gas expands freely into a vacuum (
Derivation: Rocket Engine Irreversibility
In a rocket engine, combustion is irreversible (heat
Solved Example: A JEE Main problem involves a heat engine taking
- Solution:
The Kelvin-Planck statement of the second law states that no heat engine operating in a cycle can convert all heat into work; some heat must be rejected to a cold reservoir. Thus, it cannot convert allto work. - JEE Tip: The second law prohibits 100% efficiency; a heat engine must reject some heat. Common error: Assuming 100% conversion is possible, ignoring the second law.
Solved Example: A NEET problem involves heat flowing from a cold body at 300 K to a hot body at 500 K. Is this possible spontaneously?
- Solution:
The Clausius statement states that heat cannot flow from a colder to a hotter body without external work. This process violates the second law and is not possible spontaneously.- NEET Tip: Heat flows naturally from hot to cold; reversing requires work (e.g., a refrigerator). Common error: Assuming spontaneous flow against the temperature gradient.
Solved Example: A JEE Advanced problem involves a gas undergoing free expansion. Is the process reversible?
- Solution:
In free expansion, a gas expands into a vacuum (, , ). The process is irreversible because reversing it (compressing the gas back) requires external work, increasing the surroundings’ entropy. - JEE Tip: Free expansion is a classic irreversible process; check for external work to reverse. Common error: Assuming reversibility without considering entropy changes.
Solved Example: A JEE Main problem involves a process where heat flows from 400 K to 300 K. Is this natural?
- Solution:
The second law allows heat to flow spontaneously from a hotter body (400 K) to a colder one (300 K), as it increases total entropy. Yes, it’s natural.- JEE Tip: Natural processes align with the second law’s direction; heat flows from hot to cold. Common error: Confusing the direction of spontaneous heat flow.
Application: The second law applies to power plants (efficiency limits), refrigeration, and rocketry (e.g., irreversibility in combustion processes, aligning with your interest, April 19, 2025).
20.2 Entropy and Its Calculation
Entropy quantifies the disorder of a system and provides a mathematical basis for the second law, a key concept for JEE/NEET thermodynamics problems.
Definition of Entropy
Entropy
: Infinitesimal heat transfer in a reversible process. : Absolute temperature (K). - Units: J/K.
Second Law in Terms of Entropy
The second law states that for an isolated system (or system + surroundings), the total entropy change is:
Equality holds for reversible processes; inequality for irreversible ones.
Entropy Changes in Reversible Processes
- Isothermal Process:
, where is the heat transferred at constant . - Adiabatic Process (Reversible, Isentropic):
, so . - Temperature Change (Constant Volume):
, so .
Entropy Changes in Irreversible Processes
For irreversible processes, calculate
Derivation: Entropy Change in Reversible Isothermal Process
For an ideal gas undergoing reversible isothermal expansion at
Derivation: Entropy Change for Temperature Change (Constant Volume)
For an ideal gas at constant volume,
Derivation: Entropy Change in Irreversible Free Expansion
For free expansion of an ideal gas (
Derivation: Rocket Combustion Entropy
Rocket combustion (irreversible,
Solved Example: A JEE Main problem involves calculating
- Solution:
For a reversible isothermal process,. Given , , : - JEE Tip: Isothermal
depends on volume change, not ; use . Common error: Including in the expression, which cancels out.
- JEE Tip: Isothermal
Solved Example: A NEET problem involves 2 moles of an ideal gas (
- Solution:
. Given , , , : - NEET Tip: Constant volume entropy change uses
; . Common error: Using instead of .
- NEET Tip: Constant volume entropy change uses
Solved Example: A JEE Advanced problem involves 1 mole of gas undergoing free expansion from
- Solution:
Use a reversible isothermal path:. Surroundings: , so . Thus, . - JEE Tip:
for irreversible processes; free expansion increases entropy. Common error: Assuming when .
- JEE Tip:
Solved Example: A JEE Main problem involves heat
- Solution:
, . Total: . - JEE Tip:
for irreversible heat flow; use absolute temperatures. Common error: Forgetting the negative sign for heat leaving the hot reservoir.
- JEE Tip:
Application: Entropy applies to climate modeling (entropy of Earth’s atmosphere), chemical reactions (Gibbs free energy), and rocketry (e.g., entropy changes in combustion, aligning with your interest, April 19, 2025).
20.3 Heat Engines and Refrigerators
Heat engines and refrigerators illustrate the practical implications of the second law, focusing on energy conversion and efficiency, a key topic for JEE/NEET thermodynamics problems.
Heat Engine
A heat engine operates in a cycle, absorbing heat
- Efficiency (
): .
Refrigerator
A refrigerator transfers heat
- Coefficient of Performance (COP):
.
Second Law Limitation
The second law limits efficiency:
Derivation: Heat Engine Efficiency
For a cyclic process,
Derivation: Refrigerator COP
For a refrigerator,
Derivation: Heat Engine in Rocket Systems
A rocket engine cycle (simplified) takes
Derivation: Refrigerator COP Limit
For an ideal refrigerator,
Solved Example: A JEE Main problem involves a heat engine with
- Solution:
or 37.5%. - JEE Tip: Efficiency is always less than 1; compute as a fraction or percentage. Common error: Using
directly, giving .
- JEE Tip: Efficiency is always less than 1; compute as a fraction or percentage. Common error: Using
Solved Example: A NEET problem involves a refrigerator with
- Solution:
. - NEET Tip: COP is a ratio; higher values indicate better performance. Common error: Using
instead of , requiring first.
- NEET Tip: COP is a ratio; higher values indicate better performance. Common error: Using
Solved Example: A JEE Advanced problem involves a heat engine with
- Solution:
First law:, so . - JEE Tip: Use the first law for cyclic processes;
must be positive. Common error: Assuming , making .
- JEE Tip: Use the first law for cyclic processes;
Solved Example: A JEE Main problem involves a refrigerator transferring
- Solution:
, so . - JEE Tip: Solve for
using the definition of COP; is the work input. Common error: Confusing COP with efficiency.
- JEE Tip: Solve for
Application: Heat engines apply to power generation (e.g., car engines), refrigerators to cooling systems, and rocketry (e.g., engine efficiency limits, aligning with your interest, April 19, 2025).
20.4 The Carnot Cycle and Efficiency
The Carnot cycle represents the maximum possible efficiency for a heat engine, providing a benchmark for thermodynamic performance, a key topic for JEE/NEET efficiency problems.
Carnot Cycle
The Carnot cycle consists of four reversible processes between hot (
- Isothermal Expansion: Absorbs
at , . - Adiabatic Expansion: Expands to
, , . - Isothermal Compression: Rejects
at , . - Adiabatic Compression: Returns to
, , .
Carnot Efficiency
Efficiency:
This is the maximum efficiency any engine can achieve between
Carnot Refrigerator
For a Carnot refrigerator:
Real Engines
Real engines are less efficient than Carnot due to irreversibilities (e.g., friction, heat loss).
Derivation: Carnot Efficiency
In the Carnot cycle, isothermal expansion absorbs
Derivation: Carnot Refrigerator COP
For a Carnot refrigerator,
Derivation: Carnot Efficiency in Rocket Engines
A rocket engine operating between
Derivation: Work in Carnot Cycle
Work:
Solved Example: A JEE Main problem involves a Carnot engine operating between
- Solution:
or 50%. - JEE Tip: Use absolute temperatures (K); Carnot efficiency is the theoretical maximum. Common error: Using Celsius, leading to incorrect ratios.
Solved Example: A NEET problem involves a Carnot refrigerator between
- Solution:
. - NEET Tip: Carnot COP is the maximum; higher
improves performance. Common error: Using efficiency formula instead of COP.
- NEET Tip: Carnot COP is the maximum; higher
Solved Example: A JEE Advanced problem involves a Carnot engine with
- Solution:
, so , , . - JEE Tip: Solve for
algebraically; must be in K. Common error: Forgetting to subtract from 1.
- JEE Tip: Solve for
Solved Example: A JEE Main problem involves a real engine between
- Solution:
. Real , as expected due to irreversibilities. - JEE Tip: Real engines are less efficient than Carnot; compare directly. Common error: Assuming real
equals .
- JEE Tip: Real engines are less efficient than Carnot; compare directly. Common error: Assuming real
Application: The Carnot cycle applies to theoretical engine design, refrigeration optimization, and rocketry (e.g., maximizing engine efficiency, aligning with your interest, April 19, 2025).
Summary and Quick Revision
- Second Law: Kelvin-Planck: No 100% efficient heat engine. Clausius: Heat cannot flow from cold to hot without work. Processes proceed to increase total entropy.
- Entropy:
. . Isothermal: . Constant volume: . Free expansion: . - Heat Engines and Refrigerators: Engine:
, . Refrigerator: . Second law limits , finite. - Carnot Cycle: Isothermal expansion, adiabatic expansion, isothermal compression, adiabatic compression.
, . Maximum efficiency/COP for given , . - Applications: Engine efficiency, refrigeration, entropy in natural processes, rocket propulsion.
- JEE/NEET Tips: Use Kelvin for temperatures, calculate
via reversible paths, compare real efficiencies to Carnot, verify significant figures (April 14, 2025), distinguish reversible vs. irreversible processes. - SI Units: Entropy (J/K), efficiency (dimensionless), COP (dimensionless), temperature (K), work/heat (J).
Practice Problems
Explore our problem set with 100 problems inspired by JEE Main, JEE Advanced, and NEET patterns to test your understanding.
Watch on YouTube
Our Hinglish video lessons make thermodynamics engaging! Subscribe for updates.
Animation for visualizing entropy changes, Carnot cycle, and engine efficiency coming soon!
Note: Content regularly updated to align with current JEE/NEET syllabi.